If you like DNray Forum, you can support it by - BTC: bc1qppjcl3c2cyjazy6lepmrv3fh6ke9mxs7zpfky0 , TRC20 and more...

 

Difference between attestation and domain certificate

Started by pawancarrot, Jan 28, 2023, 12:25 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

pawancarrotTopic starter

The domain example.com has a domain administrator who possesses the necessary attestation and certificate.

However, what distinguishes these two credentials? And is it not feasible to present solely an attestation or a certificate for a domain in certain situations?
  •  


scruggslaura3

Both attestation and certificate for a domain are essentially meaningless documents with no legal power.

The confirmation of domain ownership is solely reflected by an entry in the domain zone registry, subject to change at any given time. Therefore, any documentation certifying domain ownership, whether it be an attestation or a certificate, only holds validity for the brief moment it was issued.

It is necessary to maintain up-to-date records of domain ownership and regularly update these records to ensure the accuracy of the information. Failure to do so can result in loss of control over the domain or potential security breaches.
  •  

Deepak1

I have a differing opinion from the previous answer. It is important not to conflate relevance and usefulness into one category, as they are distinct concepts. One can argue that a passport may become irrelevant if it is lost or stolen and added to the register of cancelled passports with a delayed update. Similarly, many references are only valid at the time of issuance or for a short period after.

In regards to the registrar namecheap, they offer two types of "papers" (perhaps the author means documents?), which they have witnessed firsthand, despite not being an individual issued the domain.

1) The attestation of domain ownership serves no practical purpose and is merely a decorative piece of paper. Reg.ru offers this document for free during the first month after domain registration.
2) A domain name registration certificate is a stamped and signed document suitable for certain supervisory bodies or specialized companies requiring proof of domain ownership. However, it is crucial to ensure that the certificate includes complete and accurate information about the owner/organization in Russian language, rather than relying on Whois data.

For instance, mobile operators accept such certificates, even though the owner can change right after providing the certificate. The key takeaway is that there are real-world scenarios where "domain help" can be advantageous.
  •  

mbuilders

In the context of domain administration, the roles of attestation and certificate can be distinct but related.

An attestation typically refers to a declaration or verification made by an authority or individual regarding certain facts or claims. In the case of a domain administrator, an attestation might involve confirming their qualifications, expertise, or authorization to manage the domain. Attestations are often based on trust and reputation.

On the other hand, a certificate is a digital document that serves as proof of identity or authorization in the form of a cryptographic key. In the example of a domain administrator, a certificate could be issued by a trusted third-party organization, such as a certificate authority (CA), to authenticate and authorize the administrator's control over the domain.

While attestation and certificate are generally used together to establish trust and legitimacy, there could be situations where only one of them is required or feasible. For instance:

1. In some cases, an attestation alone might be sufficient to establish trust. If the domain administrator is well-known, respected, or has a long-standing reputation in the community, their attestation may carry enough credibility to validate their credentials.

2. In other instances, presenting only a certificate might be necessary to authenticate the domain administrator's identity. This is particularly relevant when a strict, standardized authentication process is required, and trust is established through cryptographic means rather than personal reputation.

Ultimately, the specific requirements and circumstances determine whether an attestation, a certificate, or both are necessary for domain administration.
  •  


If you like DNray forum, you can support it by - BTC: bc1qppjcl3c2cyjazy6lepmrv3fh6ke9mxs7zpfky0 , TRC20 and more...