Is it possible for pricing psychology to influence the sale of domain names? How important is it to determine the right pricing when selling domain names, and will even small changes have an effect on your sell-through rate?
(https://www.godaddy.com/garage/wp-content/uploads/2023/03/domain-name-pricing-target1.png)
NameFind, a domain name portfolio owned by GoDaddy, has the ability to test pricing psychology theories at scale due to its wide inventory of domains. To conduct its experiments, tens of thousands of NameFind-owned domain names are updated to run the experiment, while another set of tens of thousands of domains is maintained as a control group.
One such theory that caught the attention of NameFind is known as charm pricing, which suggests that reducing the left digit by one in the price can make domains more attractive to buyers. NameFind tested this theory by adjusting prices to end with 499 or 999 (also referred to as 499/999 price points) on thousands of domains priced between $2,500 and $10,000.
Over three months, sales data was collected and analyzed, revealing a significant increase in annual sales that can be attributed to the price change. Sales revenue increased by 22%, while the number of domains sold increased by 8%, and the average sales price increased by 13%. Even domains priced higher experienced more purchases from buyers because of the charm pricing strategy.
Overall, NameFind's testing reveals that charm pricing can lead to improved volume of BIN sales and total revenue. In fact, applying the 499/999 pricing change to a hypothetical portfolio of 10,000 domains with an initial average sale price of $3,540 could increase annual sales by nearly $100,000.
The table shows the results of NameFind's charm pricing test on domains with BIN prices between $2,500 and $10,000. The test involved adopting the 499/999 pricing strategy on 10,000 domains, resulting in a 22% increase in annual sales, an 8% increase in annual units sold, and a 13% increase in the average sale price.
NameFind then implemented the same pricing strategy on thousands of owned domains with BIN prices between $10,000 and $50,000. While there was a 21% increase in annual sales, the team attributed the increase to an increase in units sold, rather than the price change.
For domains priced under $2,500, NameFind found that more precise price points were needed than just rounding up or down to $499, $999, or $1,499. Instead, they are adopting more precise "99" price points such as $299 or $399.
These endings, also known as "charm prices," are used to create the perception of a lower price while maintaining a similar revenue level for the seller.
The psychological effect behind these endings is that people tend to perceive prices with a 9 at the end as being significantly lower than their rounded-up counterparts. For example, a domain priced at $49.99 may be perceived as being much cheaper than a domain priced at $50.00, even though the difference is only one cent.
This perception plays on the notion that consumers tend to focus on the left-most digits when evaluating prices, giving less attention to the right-most digit. As a result, they perceive the price as falling into a lower price category.
By utilizing this pricing strategy, domain sellers can take advantage of this psychological bias, making their domains seem more affordable and attracting potential buyers. It creates an illusion of value, even if the actual price difference between, let's say, $499 and $500 is negligible.
Moreover, such prices may also incite a sense of urgency in potential buyers. They may feel compelled to make a purchase since the price appears more affordable, leading to increased sales and conversions.
One reason why the 499 and 999 endings are effective is because they create a perception of value. When customers see a price that ends in 9, their brain automatically associates it with a discount or a deal. It triggers a psychological response that makes them believe they are getting a better offer compared to a rounded-up price.
Another aspect of using these endings is that they can increase the perceived affordability of a domain. For example, a domain priced at $499 may seem more affordable than a domain priced at $500, despite the actual difference being just one dollar. This can make potential buyers feel like they are getting a good deal and increase their willingness to make a purchase.
Additionally, the use of these charm prices can create a sense of urgency. Customers may feel compelled to make a decision quickly because they perceive the offer as time-limited or in high demand. The belief that they have found a great deal can drive them to act before someone else snatches up the domain.
It's important to note that while these pricing tactics can be effective, they are not foolproof. Some customers may be aware of these strategies and consider them as marketing techniques. However, for many individuals, the influence of pricing psychology is often subconscious and can still impact their decision-making process.
considerations and factors related to domain sales pricing psychology with 499 and 999 endings:
1. Comparative Pricing: Sellers often use the charm prices of 499 and 999 as a way to compare the price of their domains with competitors. By pricing their domains slightly lower, they create an impression of being more affordable and competitive in the market.
2. Perceived Quality: The use of these pricing strategies can also influence customers' perception of the quality or value of the domain. Some buyers may associate a lower price with lower quality, while others may see it as a great deal. It ultimately depends on the buyer's individual mindset and beliefs.
3. Confirmation Bias: Customers who are already motivated to buy a domain may subconsciously seek confirmation that validates their decision. Seeing a discounted price ending in 499 or 999 can act as that confirmation and reinforce their intention to make the purchase.
4. Rounding Effect: In contrast to the charm prices, using rounded-up numbers, such as $500 or $1000, may convey a more premium or exclusive feel. This approach may be suitable for higher-end domains or those targeting a specific demographic that values exclusivity.
5. Context and Perception: The effectiveness of these pricing strategies can vary depending on the context and the target audience. For example, charm prices may be more successful with budget-conscious buyers, whereas luxury or professional markets might respond more favorably to rounded-up pricing.
6. Experimentation and Testing: Like any pricing strategy, it's important for domain sellers to conduct experiments and analyze the impact of different prices. A/B testing or market research can provide insights into how different pricing techniques, including 499 and 999 endings, influence customer behavior and purchasing decisions.
some additional points to consider regarding domain sales pricing psychology with 499 and 999 endings:
1. Price Perception: The use of charm prices like 499 and 999 not only creates a perception of lower prices but also instills a sense of getting a deal or bargain. This perception can be influential in encouraging buyers to make a purchase.
2. Pricing Anchoring: By using a higher initial price and then discounting it to end in 499 or 999, sellers can create a psychological anchor for buyers. The original higher price serves as a reference point that makes the discounted price seem even more attractive.
3. Consumer Familiarity: Consumers have become accustomed to seeing charm prices in various industries, including retail and e-commerce. As a result, they may subconsciously expect to see prices like 499 or 999, and this familiarity can make the prices more appealing and trustworthy.
4. Pricing Strategies for Different Markets: The effectiveness of charm prices may vary depending on the target market and demographic. It's important to consider the preferences and buying habits of the specific audience you are targeting with your domain sales.
5. Pricing Transparency: While charm prices can be effective in attracting buyers, it's crucial to maintain transparency in your pricing. Some customers may be aware of the psychological tactics at play and appreciate straightforward pricing without gimmicks.
6. Combination with Other Pricing Strategies: Charm prices can be combined with other pricing strategies, such as tiered pricing or limited-time promotions, to further enhance their impact on buyers. Experimenting with different pricing approaches can help determine which combination works best for your specific domain sales.
7. Cultural Considerations: Keep in mind that pricing psychology can also be influenced by cultural factors. Certain cultures may have different perceptions and expectations when it comes to pricing, so it's essential to adapt your pricing strategies accordingly.