I recently came across an interesting tool for website comments - https://tolstoycomments.com . This service offers a range of benefits, resulting in increased visitor engagement. However, it has a significant drawback - the comments are not indexed and are not stored in the database.
(https://salterrasite.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/Unleashing-the-Power-of-Semantic-SEO-with-Salterra-Elevate-Your-Search-Visibility.jpg)
This raises an important question for website optimization: what is more valuable, high engagement or indexed comments? Let's consider a scenario where a blog receives 1000-10,000 comments per month. How significantly will this affect SEO positions if the comments are or are not indexed? This dilemma prompts us to carefully evaluate the trade-offs between user engagement and search engine optimization.
Tolstoycomments.com offers an interesting tool for engaging website visitors through comments, which undoubtedly contributes to a positive user experience and encourages interaction. However, the drawback of these comments not being indexed and stored in the database poses a challenge from an SEO perspective.
In the scenario where a blog receives 1000-10,000 comments per month, the decision regarding indexing becomes crucial. Indexed comments contribute to the overall content of the website, potentially adding relevant keywords and phrases that could enhance the site's visibility in search results. On the other hand, non-indexed comments do not directly contribute to the site's SEO performance.
It's important to consider the nature of the website and its primary goals. For a blog or a content-driven site, user engagement is vital, and high volumes of comments indicate an active and involved community. This can positively influence the overall user experience and the site's reputation.
However, if the primary goal is to improve search engine visibility and attract organic traffic, then prioritizing indexed content becomes more significant. Search engines use indexed content to understand the relevance and authority of a website, and non-indexed comments could mean missing out on potential keyword variations and user-generated content that could benefit SEO efforts.
The decision on whether to prioritize high engagement or indexed comments depends on the specific goals and priorities of the website. There's no one-size-fits-all answer, and careful evaluation of the trade-offs is essential to make an informed decision that aligns with the broader strategy of the website.
I'd say that the effectiveness of indexing comments depends on their quality. If the comments are substantial, at least a paragraph long and meaningful, then indexing them can be beneficial. However, if the comments consist of phrases like "Agon," "Bugaga," or "Yell like a howitzer," then it's not worth the effort. What matters more is engagement.
While indexed comments are certainly valuable, Google's behavioral factors play a much larger role in determining the significance of content. So, it's important to focus on creating engaging and substantial interactions rather than just aiming for indexed comments.
I can tell you that determining the most effective strategy is not definitive. Different individuals have their own preferences and approaches. Personally, I would opt for indexing as it offers great potential for advancement through comments.
However, the process operates in such a way that promotion is not solely based on the targeted queries, but also on additional factors. For instance, excessive keyword stuffing in the text may resemble spam, or the chosen keywords may not flow naturally within the content. Nevertheless, utilizing keywords in comments can be highly beneficial.
Moreover, I believe that people will continue to write and leave comments for behavioral reasons, albeit potentially in reduced numbers.
"Crawled – currently not indexed" – what it mean?
STEP 1: Cultivate High-Quality Content.
STEP 2: Master Your Index Coverage Monitoring.
STEP 3: Architecting Your Website for Optimal Indexing.
STEP 4: Strategically Manage Duplicate Content.
STEP 5: Mastering Direct Engagement with Google's Indexing.
It's like choosing between a warm, fuzzy feeling and a cold, hard fact. Tolstoy Comments' innovative approach is like a shot of espresso for user interaction, but it's also a shot of neglect for search engine optimization. For a blog with 1000-10,000 comments per month, I'd say the absence of indexed comments is like a missed opportunity for a high-five from Google.
I'd argue that indexed comments are the ultimate high-five, and we should strive for that rather than settling for a fleeting sense of engagement.
Unindexed website comments can impact SEO by limiting valuable user-generated content from search engines. To tackle this, enable indexing in your CMS settings, use structured data, optimize comment sections with relevant keywords, and ensure pages are crawlable. Encouraging high-quality discussions also boosts engagement and SEO value effectively.